Cole and Langston failed to find Starr after the graduation ceremony, so Cole started to fret, blaming himself for telling Starr not to visit him in jail. Cole dialed Starr's cell and thought he heard her ringtone nearby, while Bull, the creepy bald man, stalked around the halls with Starr's phone in his possession. Meanwhile, Starr took James to Viki's cabin, where she once again threatened to call the cops. He begged her not to and admitted that he stole the money because he didn't want to work for his dad's sketchy chop shop anymore. James proceeded to recap the plot of Gone In Sixty Seconds, more or less, and revealed that his father literally bullied him into stealing cars and even broke his nose. Starr asked about his mom, and James explained that his mom left when he was little. He said he came to town when he heard that Ford had been attacked, and Starr was shocked to hear that Ford is his brother.

After Cole's bail hearing, Marty was spooked by Hannah's threatening behavior at the courthouse. John walked in and sensed the tension, but Hannah flashed him a smile and said they were "celebrating" Cole's release. John asked Hannah to sit down, then proceeded to ask if she was in the stairwell the day Marty fell, because some fibers from a blue sweater like one that she owns were found there. Hannah immediately became defensive and said she has nothing to do with Marty's accident and stormed out. John told Marty he's certain that Hannah is hiding something, and she agreed.

Jessica met up with Kelly at the Buenos Dias and reported that Dr. Levin believes she is still integrated and that her alters did not reemerge to attack Ford. Jessica still thought this meant she could have attacked Ford, so she wanted to confront the victim himself. Kelly didn't think that was a good idea, but Jessica was resolved to speak with Ford. At a nearby table, Nate introduced Danielle to his mom, Inez, who was impressed with the pretty teen. They sat down to lunch, and Nate surprised his mom with the cashier's check, just as Bull walked in. Bull called his boss and said "the kid" claims he lost the money, then phoned James and urged him to pay up. He threatened to hunt James and his "little girlfriend" down, which put the fear of God in James. Meanwhile, Nate lied to his mom that he played the lottery and got this money from a winning ticket. Inez didn't buy it, pointing out that the state doesn't issue lotto tickets to minors, so Nate explained that he used a fake ID to collect the money. Inez accepted the money and promised to set some of it aside for Nate's college education. Once Dani and Nate were gone, Inez opened the newspaper and was intrigued by a story about Ford.

Langston and Cole returned to La Boulaie to feed Hope, and Langston asked if he could forgive her for hurting his best friend. Cole couldn't even think about that situation at the moment, since he was so focused on finding Starr. At the cabin, Starr decided to call Cole and tried to come up with a way to explain why she won't be coming home anytime soon. Cole let a call from Hannah go to voicemail, but when he saw another call coming in, he answered and was relieved to hear Starr's voice on the other end.

Cristian and Layla visited their roommate at the hospital. Ford was thrilled ... until the couple explained they're not there on a friendly visit. Since Markko is his friend and was devastated by Ford's affair with Langston, Cris wanted Ford to move out. Once they were gone, Ford resumed looking at a note that he'd found on his meal tray. Jessica arrived at the hospital in her quest to talk to Ford and ran into Layla and Cristian on her way in. She apologized to them for trying to break them up while she was sick, but it was already water under the bridge. Kelly accompanied her in to visit Ford, while Jessica asked point-blank if she attacked him. He claimed he doesn't remember, but when the ladies were gone, he resumed reading his note, then called John to ask him to come to the hospital. Once John was there, Ford announced that he remembers who attacked him.