Natalie and Jared watched the security TV while Viki explored downstairs. Both screamed for Viki, who decided she was imagining things. When Nat screamed as Viki walked toward upstairs, Viki turned around, unsure of what she'd heard, but brushed it off and went upstairs. Jared tried to comfort Natalie, who was glad that he was finally with her. She and Jared cleared the air about her phony break-up letter. Natalie told him that even if they were stuck there forever, she'd be okay now because they were together.

John and Janet argued. John wanted answers, but Janet insisted she had never seen Marty before. He warned Janet that she could lose everything by lying. The cop went down the list of Janet's aliases, including Lee Halpern and Carol Dennison. Her list of crimes included a prostitution ring. While Janet reminded John of the statute of limitations on those crimes, he warned that he could still make her life a living hell. Janet insisted that she was just Todd's housekeeper, and that everyone who was in Todd's house wanted to be there. John asked who "everybody" was. He then tried another approach, detailing Marty's life, including Cole and the rape. While Janet was taken aback by news of the rape, she stuck to her guns about not knowing anything. John let her go. In a private moment, Janet nearly lost it before leaving the station.

Todd and Dr. Joplin exchanged barbs. The doctor sarcastically went over their plan. She asked him if Marty had any idea about his true nature. Dr. Joplin then got a phone call about Starr. When Todd asked if the phone call was about his daughter, she replied, "Maybe. Now you have to decide — are you going to make this the worst night of her entire life?"

Starr panicked as she experienced pains. Blair told her to breathe, while a clueless Marcie arrived and thought Starr was practicing. While Marcie and Blair wanted to call Michael (he was on duty), Starr insisted they call Dr.
Joplin. Blair and Marcie tried to calm Starr down, but both shut up when Blair mentioned Todd. Later, Dr. Joplin tended to Starr as Todd listened in. After relieving Starr by telling her she wasn't going into labor, Starr thanked her and told her how much she trusted her. Todd threatened Dr. Joplin about Marcie. The doctor predicted that Starr would deliver a healthy, happy baby. Blair happily told Marcie that she would finally have a baby that wouldn't be taken away from her. The three joyfully looked through baby names.

Marty wrote about Todd in her journal, and also noted she felt a connection to the flowers. Todd checked up on her, who told him to go be with Starr. Marty continued writing in her journal, excited at the prospect of raising a baby with Todd. However, she wrote that although she should feel complete with her life, she felt like if she left Llanview she'd be leaving something behind. But what? Later, Janet returned, and Marty noticed something was on her mind. Janet reached out to Marty, making sure she was all right. Todd returned and asked Janet if she wanted to leave Llanview with them. A troubled Janet was indecisive and hurriedly left. Marty asked Todd if he wanted to rethink moving away, mentioning that Starr may want to be there for the baby. Todd quickly changed the subject. Marty brought up baby names. As the two enjoyed their time together, Todd looked on as Marty happily wrote names down.

Viki and Tess argued as Cain passed out from the poisoned dip. Tina found herself needing Tess' help, afraid that Cain would try to kill her when he wakes up. Tina begged Tess for help with Cain. Not to be outsmarted, Tina asked her niece what she was going to do when Viki realized everything. Tess tried scare tactics, but Tina, no stranger to blackmail, warned Tess not to bother. Tina promised that if she was found out, she'd see to it that Tess ended up strapped to a bed at St. Ann's while Jared and Natalie would be free and enjoying their lives. Tess changed the subject to the problem at hand — there was a man out cold on the floor and Viki was sure to discover him. Viki walked into the study to find it empty. When Tess rushed back inside, Viki was suspicious. Before Tess could explain herself, Tina ran in to greet Viki. Tess and Tina confused Viki, who knew something was off. While the two schemers tried to get Viki to go to sleep, a hungry Viki went for the dip. A guilty Tina blurted out that it was poisoned, but Tess did damage control by saying it had been left out too long. Tina covered, saying she was worried about Sarah and Christian. Viki called Jared, but the reception was so bad that the call was dropped. Viki tried calling him back, but the service was dead. Tess came down to gloat and get Jared's phone. He told her to go to hell. Viki and Tina discussed "Jessica" and Natalie patching things up as Cain started to come to. Back at the secret room, Tess threatened to hurt Viki if Jared didn't hand over the phone. Jared angrily gave up his cell. Tess smirked, saying the reception was perfect. Tess and Tina finally got Viki to sleep. When they went outside to check on Cain, however, he was gone.