2001
Timmy published a furious Tabitha's memoirs, which included several Harmony residents' dark secrets. The two fled town so those written about wouldn't come after her. They stayed in a secluded Bates-like motel, where they ran across an ax-wielding woman, Norma. Escaping, they returned to Harmony, where Hecuba took Kay's soul and had sent Charity to Hell. Tabitha trapped Hecuba in a bottle and retrieved the vial containing Kay's soul. Briefly, the Bennetts moved in with Tabitha when their house sank. Town nerd Reese spied a headless Tabitha after Timmy accidentally got too worked up with a sword trying to stop the vial-holding necklace from choking his princess. Then, Norma popped up in Harmony and Tabitha and Timmy fled again to avoid her. They hid out on Warlock Island, but she followed; they sought refuge on a boat, but it caught fire. Miguel saved Tabitha, who in turn rescued Timmy. Fleeing Norma, they fell into a pit and the nut threw bugs in after them. Timmy chanted for water to kill the tiny creatures, but accidentally started a hurricane. Returned home, Tabitha thrilled to a new ally in Kay, who would do anything to separate Miguel and Charity. Tabs showed her the Spells of Pain book, from which the teen learned to transform herself into her cousin Charity. At last, their house rebuilt, the Bennetts moved out of Tabitha's home.

2002
Excited by mystery and mayhem, Tabitha reported Julian's shooting to a tabloid -- and brought evidence from the crime scene to the cops. Timmy upset her when he left town in search of the Demon Horn to help save a frozen Charity. He eventually returned home, but their reunion was short-lived; Timmy died playing hero for Charity. While mourning sweet Timmy, Tabitha and Julian sought comfort in one another and had a crazy sex romp (including hysterical role-playing costumes). Not long after that, Tabitha was visited by mysterious dancing babies. Zombie Charity made an evil living doll named Cracked Connie as company for Tab.

2003
That sex romp with Julian got 300-year-old Tabitha pregnant (talk about late in life), and at the same time an expecting Kay moved in after a fight with her mother. Only then did Kay figure out that her hostess was a witch. The two partnered to cause mayhem throughout Harmony and, in particular, to prevent Charity and Miguel from being together. Alone, Tabitha went into labor, but Julian and Rebecca arrived in time to help her deliver her demonic daughter, Endora, who now wears very adorable pointed black hats....