Kendall and Erica brought Ian home. For a brief moment Kendall thought Myrtle was Zach, but realized it wasn't him and brought Ian over for an introduction. Kendall promised Ian that his dad was trying his hardest to come home to them. Josh showed up at the door with balloons and presents, saying he knew how Zach would want that day to go. He also said he would like to fill in for Zach until he came home. Erica called Jack and left him a message saying they were all waiting for him at Kendall's. She admitted to Myrtle that she and Jack were having problems. Kendall had a daydream in which Zach came home.

Tad, Jack, Hannah and Derek discussed Greenlee and Zach's disappearance over the Thanksgiving holiday. After a reminder from Julia that there was a child in earshot, they stopped and everyone sat down. Joe said a prayer for their loved ones, and they went around the table saying what they were thankful for. Adam said he was thankful for JR's year of sobriety. As everyone chowed down, Adam pulled JR aside and apologized for making that comment publicly. JR angrily blew him off. Jack got a call from Erica as he chatted with Opal. He ignored the call. Joe approached Jack with Greenlee's commitment papers, and told him Mary's signature had been forged: Erica was behind it. Derek got a call confirming that the blood was a match for Zach, and as he looked at JR, said they had a suspect. Later, JR saw Derek talking with two cops outside and bolted, unnoticed.

Babe was incredulous that Ryan and Annie were trying to use her against Richie. Jonathan and Ava walked in, and, quickly realizing they had interrupted something, made their way out to the terrace. Outside, they discussed their bad Thanksgiving memories, and the beginning of new, better holidays together. Jon asked what was going on with JR; he heard he was bugging her at The Comeback the other day. Ava told him it was nothing, and they went back inside. Annie was unable to convince Babe, and Babe was about to leave when Emma convinced her to stay. Everyone played with Emma and Little Adam as they waited for Richie.

Amanda informed her mother that it was Thanksgiving, and they sat down to eat. Janet could barely remember anything, which was a side effect of her meds. Amanda confided in her the problems she'd been having with JR. Janet suggested someone set Babe and JR straight. Amanda told her that she had already taken care of JR, but before she had a chance to tell her what she'd done, Janet grabbed her head and when she let go she'd completely forgotten the entire conversation, or that Amanda had even been there.

A man called down to Zach and Greenlee, and they told him they were trapped. They were unaware they were actually talking to Richie. Before "going for help," Richie, who was barely hanging on himself, confirmed that it was Zach Slater down there — the same man Kendall Hart Slater was desperately looking for. Greenlee panicked when the man stopped responding to them. She and Zach sniped at each other, but before long Zach was barely hanging on to consciousness. Meanwhile, Richie found a large sheet of metal, and dragged it toward the hole. Greenlee was about to give Zach an aspirin when she heard activity overhead and assumed it was someone coming to rescue them. They both looked up as the hole was covered, and Zach realized the man hadn't been there to save them. Meanwhile, Aidan returned to the cabin where he had last seen Greenlee and got to work on his laptop.