Willis showed up at the Lavery penthouse. Jesse arrived and Willis explained that Emma is an eyewitness to Stuart's murder. Jesse cautioned Willis against taking stock in anything Annie says. Adam revealed to Annie that he had read her files and her journal from Oak Haven. Annie was upset at his appearent loss of faith in her but her words of devotion moved him.

Liza showed up at the Martins unexpectedly and heard baby Trevor crying. Amanda, Jake and Taylor tried to keep the baby hidden and Tad pretended to remember more about the night of the murder to distract her. His wild rantings prompted Liza to suggest that he needs professional help. Tad kissed Liza to allow his hidden guests to escape. Back at Taylor's, Taylor and Jake assured Amanda that the baby would be fine there. Tad met them there with baby supplies. With difficulty, Amanda handed the baby off to Taylor. Tad offered to stay and help Taylor babysit. They had a blast with the baby, while back at home, Amanda's heart hurt to be separated from her son and Jake did his best to comfort her. She reiterated her gratitude to him for bringing her baby back to her.

At the Chandler manse, Annie told Zach that she wasn't afraid of him. The cops arrived and Jesse arrested Zach for trespassing. At the station, Jesse insisted to Willis that Zach doesn't know where Emma is. Jesse told Zach that he shares his belief that Annie is using Emma to set up Kendall. Zach made a remark about Randi. Liza arrived and Willis grilled her about Emma's whereabouts.... Jesse returned to the manse and Annie laid into him for not taking Emma's account seriously. Jesse told Annie that he's on her side and wants to help her. The phone rang (it was Emma calling). "Do you want to get that?" Jesse remarked to Annie.

Kendall barged into the safehouse where Ryan and Erica had taken Emma and implored the little girl to admit that Annie shot Stuart. Ryan pulled Kendall away. Kendall apologized for scaring Emma. Emma insisted that she wasn't lying. While Erica spoke to Kendall, Ryan scolded Kendall for her behavior and insisted that he would not push Emma. Erica encouraged Kendall to go home, assuring her that she could trust Ryan to handle Emma. Emma stuck to her story when Ryan rejoined her.

Zach and Kendall caught up at their house. Kendall said that she had gone to see Emma and it hadn't gone well. Zach was upset with her for continuing to screw up her own defense. Kendall, however, was determined to prove that Emma is lying. Liza came over and wanted to speak to Emma herself, thinking they could beat Annie at her own game.