Craig showed up at the precinct with donuts for Margo and asked his sister if she'd heard about his heroics. Margo was unimpressed and suggested he go spend time with Katie.... Seeing Brad tried to prepare her breakfast, Katie agreed to forget about Craig as long as Brad stops trying to have him arrested. Brad refused to let the Craig fiasco go, so Katie left in a huff.

Tom met Dusty at the Lakeview, and Dusty made it clear that he is purposely antagonizing Craig. He reasoned that when Craig lashes out at him it will be his own undoing.... Craig dropped by the Lakeview and tried to say hello to Johnny. Dusty rebuffed him until Craig whipped out years-old documents granting him visitation rights. As the two men glared at each other, Tom cautioned them to take it easy. Craig said he wanted to take Johnny to ride a train and after Tom advised Dusty that he has to let Craig see his son, Dusty agreed. Alone, Tom told Dusty the only way he can keep Craig from Johnny is to petition for full custody.

Jack was peeved when he showed up with a present for Parker and Carly thought he was Craig. Jack was further dismayed to learn Parker was at school and grilled Carly about why she looked so nice. Was she meeting Craig, he wanted to know. Carly begged Jack to stop pestering her and flaunting his newlywed bliss in her face. As Carly claimed that Craig wasn't coming over, guess who rang the bell? Craig and Johnny. Carly took the tot into the kitchen while Craig and Jack had a tense chat. As soon as Jack left, Craig brought up the subject of marriage and complimented Carly on her mothering skills.

Dusty visited Brad and urged him to come clean about how Craig manipulated Katie. Brad resolved that if Jack could tell him Katie wouldn't face a perjury charge, he'll spill the beans about his brother-in-law.... Katie met Margo at Java to ask what would happen to "friends" of hers if they lied to the police. Margo correctly guessed Katie was talking about herself. Meanwhile, Brad headed to the police station and got Jack's take on perjury. He too correctly, guessed the subjects involved were Katie and Craig. Jack called Margo to fill her in on what Brad said and told her where she could find Craig. Katie was furious to hear that Brad blabbed. Margo went to Milltown to give Craig a "courtesy call" about his case and unraveling alibi. Carly remarked that if he doesn't help his sister, she's through with him. Craig wondered if she would marry him if he assisted Katie. He went on to admit that if he tries to raise Johnny alone he'll screw the kid up and lamented not being there for Bryant and his estrangement from Lucy.

At the precinct, Katie read Brad the riot act for going to the police. Margo and Jack readied Brad and Katie to make their statements.... Dusty met Tom at Java and let him know that the Paul Ryan car bombing case was still open. Tom questioned if Dusty is out to get revenge on Craig or to protect Johnny. The barrister warned Dusty that he could end up poisoning Johnny against his father. Afterward, they returned to the stationhouse. Craig showed up with Johnny and had yet another face off with Dusty. Katie spent time with Johnny, changed her mind about outing Craig and ran out.

Back at home, Katie and Brad continued to argue about Craig and he accused her of choosing Craig over him. Montgomery retreated to Carly's with flowers and champagne, but she still wouldn't agree to marry him.... At the Lakeview, Johnny told Dusty he likes having two daddies.