Carly worried to Henry that she won't be able to keep Metro afloat. Craig arrived to check on his "investment" but Carly pointed out that his money was a loan and didn't buy into her establishment. Henry proposed that they start serving a signature drink called the Hope-tini, but Craig tasted the drink and deemed it awful. After Henry left, Craig urged Carly to "think bigger." He suggested that she come up with a designer vodka with "an out of this world" label. Carly was intrigued by the idea but balked at Craig getting involved with the venture. He outlined that she would be the image, while he would provide the funds for distribution and an ad campaign. Carly doubted that people would pay for a bottle of fancy booze in this economy but Craig posed that she needs to start living the life she deserves. Carly agreed and but told Craig that their arrangement is "completely business." They started test tasting different vodkas and decided theirs would be called Midnight Sun. Since they were now both plastered, Carly called for a cab.

Brad came home with "a feast of comfort food" but found a frisky Katie wanting to have sex. He reminded that doctor's orders called for her to rest so she grudgingly changed back into her sweats and worried that she wouldn't be able to get pregnant. He assured that everything would be fine but had to leave when he got excited from kissing his wife. He later found Henry at the hotel bar and related how Katie can't get pregnant for a while. "She has to wait," Brad lamented and Henry advised Brad to "put your foot down" when it came to having sex with Katie. Meanwhile, Katie was becoming increasingly upset over her baby dreams, so she trashed her birth control, then tracked down Brad. After Henry walked away, Brad couldn't help himself when Katie opened her trench coat to flash him so they returned home. Katie assured that she had taken proper precautions and they crashed into bed.

Dusty accused Josie of helping Paul to kidnap Eliza but she explained what really happened and that Paul was taking the baby home to Meg. Dusty refused to believe that Paul was giving up his daughter, so Josie drove Dusty over to where she last saw Paul. They searched rental car agencies but came up empty handed.

Paul freaked when the carjacker drove off with Eliza. He then called Meg with news that their daughter "is gone." He swore to get "our little girl back" but Meg demanded to know where Paul was. He hung up, then called Barbara and let her know how he lost Eliza. Barbara headed to New York to meet her son but also brought an angry Meg. Paul apologized profusely but she blasted him for his actions. He wanted to canvas the neighborhood for information and Meg insisted on coming with them but they immediately encountered Dusty and Josie. Dusty had to be stopped from manhandling Paul and Barbara advised they all put their heads together to find Eliza. Dusty wanted to call the police but Paul warned Meg that he could go to jail for a long time. Meg wanted the cops to be called anyway. Later, Paul spotted his rental car parked on the street but the baby seat in the back was empty. "Where's my baby?!" Meg screamed, then fell into Dusty's arms.