Janet vented to Father Farley about Liberty's troubles and then urged Liberty to talk to the priest about her "options." Liberty noted her mother needed to let her do what's right for her. Father Farley reminded her that she was baptized Catholic. Brad burst in to offer his take. Jack, meanwhile, dropped by to see Parker, who refused to stay away from Liberty during this tough time. Father Farley made a hasty exit as Brad hugged Liberty and asked her what she wants to do now. "I can't have this baby," she confessed. Brad promised her he'd handle her mother. Liberty met up with Parker at Java and updated him. Parker had a solution: "Marry me." Liberty reminded him of their previous, failed marriage. Parker said he loved her, as a friend, and it could solve her problems. Liberty countered by asking what made him think they could make a marriage and a baby work. Back at the farm, Brad accused Janet of bringing the priest for herself, because of her own guilt and shame. "From what I hear, God's pretty forgiving," he noted. Janet brought up the potential what ifs, insisting the baby was already a part of Liberty. Later, Jack and Janet discussed their kids' drama. At Java, Lib noted she doesn't want a baby or to feel trapped in a marriage. Brad walked in, dubbing the idea to get married "insane." Liberty got huffy with everyone trying to run her life. Brad told Liberty he'd support any decision she made, and she asked him if he would've wanted Janet to have an abortion. Brad said he didn't know how to answer that — Liberty was the best thing that had ever happened to him, but what was right for Janet didn't have to be right for her. They hugged. Then, Parker and Lib promised Brad they'd tell a parent before they made any big decisions. Janet realized all she had to do was stall Liberty until the safe period to have an abortion passed and then the decision would be made for her. Back at Java, a sobbing Liberty wished she could have just had the abortion in Chicago. At Al's, Brad told Janet he'd support whatever Lib decided and Janet calmly agreed with his supportive stance.

Damian visited Lily, who was going through Holden's paperwork and feeling lost. He comforted her with a hug. Down in Kentucky, cranky Eb continued to question Holden about Skaggs' money. Maeve said she had to go to Paducah to visit a cousin and sent Eb out to the porch with beer. Once alone, Maeve told Holden she'd go to the bank and get his money today... and then she kissed him! She made excuses to Eb and left. Alone, Holden earned Eb's ire and a smack in the face. Holden kept covering for Maeve and Eb accused him of being "sweet on her." Lily was insistent upon doing Holden's bank work so Damian offered to go with her. Jack voiced his dislike of that idea. Lily made the men stop presuming to know what Holden would want. Lily told Jack that she keeps refusing his help because he reminds her of Holden and Damian doesn't. Ouch! They hugged and then Jack left. In Kentucky, Holden denied anything was going on with Maeve and Eb pulled his gun on him, determined to learn where the money is. At the bank, Damian comforted a rattled Lily...as Maeve arrived to make a withdrawal! When the bank asked for Maeve's ID, she fled. The bank teller told Lily what was going on and she boggled: Maeve's paper had Holden's signature! Lily watched Maeve on the security footage, baffled. Back at the Cabin o' Chains, Eb repeatedly dunked Holden's head in a tin tub of water. Lily came home with a copy of Holden's letter, determined to match up his handwriting. "He could be alive!" she declared, incensed. Damian said Maeve was probably a scam artist, noting that Holden would try to contact her if he were indeed alive. Maeve returned home in time to stop Holden's water torture and drag Eb off to have marital relations. Back at Lily's, Damian urged her to take a sleeping pill and get some rest. Then, he grabbed the samples of Holden's writing and left. Back at Eb and Maeve's, Maeve told Holden about her botched bank job and how she'd seen Lily with Damian. She hugged Holden and assured him they'd work everything out.