A distraught Katie confronted Stephen with photos from the video and accused him of shooting Stephanie. Stephen asked Katie where she got those images, and discredited them as being doctored. Donna came to his defense and Brooke remained skeptical, but Katie insisted he was guilty. Donna became insulted by Katie's accusations. Meanwhile, Stephanie was convinced it was Stephen's hand on the still image on the computer monitor. Pam asked if she was sure. Stephanie said yes because of Stephen's ring, and said she was going over to Brooke's to confront him. Eric insisted he accompany her. Soon, Stephanie and Eric arrived at Brooke's and requested a confession from Stephen to prevent things from going to trial. "Are you man enough?" Stephanie challenged. Stephen maintained his innocence as Lt. Baker arrived. Eric showed Lt. Baker the incriminating video footage. The officer rearrested Stephen for breaking into Stephanie's home earlier. Stephen asked for a moment with Brooke before he was taken to jail. He pleaded with Brooke to believe in his innocence. "I can't clear myself from a jail cell. Will you help me?" Stephen asked. "I believe you, Dad," whispered Brooke. The two hugged, as Brooke vowed to find out who framed him.

Nick welcomed Taylor home, and caught her up on all the details of Stephanie's shooting. Taylor happily spent quality time with baby Jack then put him down for a nap. Nick and Taylor snuggled and cozied up in bed together. Taylor felt guilty and thought she should go back and check on Jack, but Nick alleviated Taylor of any residual guilt about her past reluctance to bond with the child.

Pam got a call from Ann, who observed that Pam left her medicine behind in Chicago. Ann asked Pam if she shot her sister. Pam insisted she loved her sister, but acknowledged that things weren't going so well. Still suspecting the worst, Ann instructed Pam to pack up her things and her dog and return to Chicago ASAP.