Nick and Bridget helped Katie get settled in. She felt bad for breaking in on their peaceful evening but Nick revealed that Donna and Eric were coming over anyway. The newlyweds arrived and Donna was armed with an album of wedding photos for Katie to look over. After Nick assured Eric that he and Bridget were trying to figure out the next step in their relationship, Eric had to leave to for a conference call to Singapore. Donna opted to stay and while Nick and Bridget walked Eric out, Katie found the baby photo of Marcus that Donna hid in the album. "Who's this?" Katie asked and Donna abruptly snatched the snapshot out of her sister's hand. After some pressing from Katie, Donna broke down and confessed that she had a baby in high school. "This could be my son," she sobbed, then lamented that she sent Marcus away. Katie asked if Donna knew who the father is and Donna snapped that she did.

At Insomnia, Phoebe stared at a photo of her and Rick together. Marcus showed up and asked if he could join her. She agreed and he noticed the picture she was holding. Phoebe opened up about not wanting to get serious but now she's ready "He's the type of guy any girl would want to marry," Phoebe gushed. Meanwhile, Taylor came home to find a half-naked Rick waiting in her bed. He started to get frisky but she begged off until they talked to Phoebe, who was coming home the next day. "I want to make love with you but I can't," Taylor whined but Rick still maneuvered her into bed. As they were kissing passionately, Phoebe suddenly came into the room. "What are you doing?" she shrieked.