Mia was stunned to see Chad, who said he was back in Salem for the summer and missed her. Mia flashed back to getting hot and heavy with Chad in the back of his car. Back to the present, Mia told Chad to leave. Chad followed Mia around, insisting they talk. Evan interrupted, telling Mia he got someone to cover her shift. Chad thought that was great. They'd have time to catch up. "We're over,” announced Mia, insisting she never wanted to see him again. After Mia left, Chad talked to Evan, who gave him a job at Java Café.

EJ served Sami with a court order for custody of Johnny. "Just like you took my daughter from me. And eye for an eye,” seethed EJ. Sister Agnes arrived at the church and Father Matt started to introduce her to Nicole. Sister Agnes said she already knew Nicole. Nicole said she must have her confused with someone else. Rafe told EJ what he was doing was wrong. Will interrupted and asked EJ for permission to visit his brother. EJ granted it. Will turned to leave. Sami begged him to stop. Will barked that EJ had every right to do what he was doing, since Sami and Rafe lied to him about Grace. Rafe promised Sami they'd fight this. Sami and EJ fought. Nicole interrupted. Sami yelled this was all Nicole's fault. EJ told Sami she had one hour to bring him Johnny. Sami left, and Father Matt approached EJ. "Don't do anything you will regret," he warned. EJ accused Sami of being the one who tried to play God. Nicole approached Sami, noting she had nothing to do with EJ's court order. Later, Nicole told EJ that maybe Sami didn't tell him about Grace because she hated her. EJ left to get Johnny, as Nicole prayed and sobbed.

Kate summoned Daniel to the Kiriakis terrace via telephone. Chris arrived with a dish of appetizers for the Hearth and Home shoot. After he left, Kate slipped on gloves and poisoned the food. Daniel arrived and Kate gave him a letter, promising all the proceeds from him doing the show would go to the cancer charity of his choice. She also noted she'd put the whole situation with him and Chloe behind her and suggested they drink to "new beginnings.” Kate and Daniel clinked their glasses in a toast. When Daniel left, Kate lifted his fingerprints from his glass and put them on the bottle of poison. Meanwhile, at Maggie's house, Chloe prepared for the shoot, as Lucas and Maggie sensed her uneasiness. Maggie approached Chloe about not being over Daniel. Will phoned Lucas and said they had to talk in person. Lucas left to meet his son. Chloe ran after him and ended up running into the arriving Daniel. Lucas met Will at the pier and confronted his dad about knowing the truth about Grace. Then, he dropped the bomb about EJ taking Johnny from Sami. Lucas ra n off to support Sami. Mia found Will, who sensed something was wrong. Mia didn't want to talk about it. Back at the shoot, Chris gave Chloe and Daniel direction on how to make the show fun. Kate arrived and took charge, toting the poisoned appetizers. She cooed that they were "to die for tasty." Daniel handed Chloe one of the tainted treats.

Sami and Rafe were back at her apartment. Same announced she'd just spoken to Mickey and had no choice but to comply with EJ's court order. She had to take Johnny to EJ. Rafe promised to help her fight this. Rafe left, and Sami packed up Johnny's things. Lucas arrived and explained he knew what was going on. He promised to help Sami fight this. Later, Sami arrived at the DiMera mansion with Johnny. EJ was icy cold, telling her to shut the door on her way out.

Nicole paid a visit to Grace's grave, remembering how she helped deliver her a few short months ago. She lamented switching Grace with Sydney. Nicole wondered if that caused Grace's death or it was just her time to pass away. Nicole asked God to forgive her as she broke down and sobbed, "Oh Grace. I would do anything to bring you back." A confused Rafe looked on.