Carly was worried that Hope was going to turn her in. Bo insisted they could trust her. The conversation turned to Justin. Bo urged Carly to tell Justin the whole truth about why she killed Lawrence. Carly said she couldn't. They caught up about what had happened since Carly had been gone. She looked at a photo of Zack and asked who it was. Bo told her, then admitted he and Hope never really resolved their feelings over his death. He added that Hope would be first in line to help Carly if she knew what was really going on with Dr. Manning.

At the Kiriakis mansion, Victor asked Hope why she was upset. She didn't want to talk about it, but noted that Bo had found happiness with two other women. Victor insisted that Hope was the love of Bo's life. Hope casually brought up Lawrence's murder. Vic asked if Hope was worried that Carly would come back to town. He assured her that wouldn't happen. They talked about Carly. Vic noted that while she saved his life, she was a predator. Justin came home. Hope told him about her conversation with Victor. She then grabbed the phone and asked for a moment alone. He went upstairs. She made a call.

Carly fell asleep and had a nightmare of Lawrence, who had a knife and stabbed Bo. Bo woke her up. She flipped out and said she was leaving. She opened the door to find federal agents standing there. "Carly Manning, you are under arrest for the murder of Lawrence Alamain," one said and cuffed her.

Philip ran into Melanie at Java Café, who revealed she had a date with Nathan. He asked why she would go out with Nathan when she could be with him. He said they were meant to be together, then kissed her. Turned out, Melanie's was daydreaming. She opened her eyes to find Nathan there. He kissed her. She assured him she was going to have the best date of his life. They headed to Nathan's new place; he showed her his bedroom. They began kissing then fell on the bed. Before things got too far, Nathan was called to the hospital. He left and Melanie immediately thought of being in bed with Philip.

On the pier, EJ came upon Ari crying and handed her a handkerchief. She tried to walk away from him, but he grabbed her. She said she didn't like creeps grabbing her arms. He apologized, then said he was worried about her. They traded barbs about Rafe. EJ asked why she was sad earlier. She said it was none of his business.

Sami and Rafe basked in the glow of their reunion. Nicole came home so Rafe hid. Nic and Sami discussed Mia and her lies. Nicole asked if Sami had seen Sydney's teething ring (which Rafe swiped earlier). They looked for it. Sami was curious if Nicole was nervous to get the DNA results for Sydney back. Nicole said she was sure everything would be fine. Sami remarked that she would hate to think of anyone taking Sydney away from Nic. Nicole declared that she wouldn't let it happen. Nic then had to go to the store, so Sami said she would watch Syd. Once alone with Rafe again, Sami marveled how she and Nicole were so close in light of their past. Rafe was about to talk to her about Nicole, then decided not to. Rafe headed back to Ari's. Sami was in heaven that her guy was home. Rafe called his friend at the FBI and said he had secured the DNA samples. Arianna came home and asked if he was worried that the truth about Sydney might bring EJ and Sami closer together.

Sami took Sydney to the DiMera mansion to pick up Johnny because EJ didn't drop him off. EJ came rushing in and apologized. EJ was uncomfortable around the baby. Sami mentioned she had cut a new tooth, then asked if EJ wanted to hold her. He said no. She started talking to the baby in a playful manner, which annoyed EJ. Sami told him she just wanted him to be happy.

Brady sat alone at Java, upset over Arianna's betrayal. He headed out; Nicole found him outside the pub. She apologized for asking him to help her leave town. She could tell he was upset. He told her he and Ari had split. She said she was sorry, then hugged him. They parted ways.