Rayner demanded that Jason give him evidence incriminating Sonny or else Jason and Spinelli would be in trouble. Jason suggested Rayner file charges against him and leave Spinelli out of it, but Rayner refused. Soon, Diane arrived and stated that her client, Jason, was being wrongfully detained. Rayner was determined to arrest Jason and Spin.

Meanwhile, Sam was caught by FBI Agent Compton, who demanded to see her ID. They were interrupted by Winnifred, who called Sam "Agent Sam" and got her out of there just in time.

Spinelli, Lulu and Maxie sat and ate together at Lulu and Johnny's place; Lulu then argued with Johnny over him wanting to go to the "mob party" and left the room. Spin and Maxie urged Johnny to make amends with Lulu. Spinelli then told Maxie and Johnny that he knew they'd kissed. Maxie explained how she'd told Spin she was going to sleep with Johnny as a desperate ploy to keep Spinelli from leaving town. Just then, the FBI knocked on the door; Spinelli opened it and accepted his arrest. Maxie blamed herself for Spin's predicament. Johnny then confided in her how he feels Claudia is in over her head being wed to Sonny and he feels like he has to protect her. Maxie noted that Johnny didn't deserve Lulu and she didn't deserve Spinelli. "If I lose Spinelli, that's it for me," Maxie said. "My heart will be closed for business."

Jax returned to his and Carly's hotel suite and they ended up in bed. They declared how lucky they are to have reunited. Carly reminded him how she insisted that they belong together. "I've never stopped loving you," he replied. Carly thanked him for forgiving her. "You forgave me for a few things, as well," he admitted. He suggested they make a pact: that whatever happened, they'd find a way to get through it. She wanted them to have a clean slate. Later, they agreed on what to have for dessert. When Carly stepped out, Jax watched the DVD from Jerry about Michael's shooting; in it, Jerry named himself, Claudia and Ian as being responsible for it. Later, Jax promised Carly that nothing would ever come between them again.

As Carly listened, Ric told Sonny that Sonny needed to "desperately know" something that had to deal with Claudia. Sonny demanded that they tell him what was going on, and what this "information" was. Ric explained that he knew a lot, thanks to his relationships with Zacchara and Trevor. Ric then asked Claudia if he was in or out of the organization. Claudia didn't want to play his game, but Ric insisted she say what she think. Claudia didn't think Ric could be trusted ... but thought he could be useful for Sonny. She advised Sonny to give him a place; Sonny thought she was out of her mind. Later, they argued over Ric. Claudia reminded Sonny that she's on his side.

Patrick eavesdropped on Robin, a.k.a. "Nancy" saying goodnight to Brad by the motel. She called Brad sweet and thanked him for being there when she needed him. Brad said he respects the fact that she has someone at home and wished her a good life. Robin then went into her motel room and sat down on her bed and stared out into space. After, a mistaken Patrick confided in Elizabeth that Robin cheated with another guy (even though she hadn't actually done so). Liz noted that things were complicated since Robin was suffering from postpartum depression, but Patrick couldn't help but take it personally. He asked how she felt when Lucky was hooked on drugs, then apologized for the low blow. Liz sympathized with what Drake was going through. Patrick teared up as he admitted that out of all the things he anticipated going through with Robin, this was never it. He wondered if his wife would even come home; Liz assured him that Robin would return. He asked Liz to keep this secret and didn't even want Robin to know that he saw her with another man. Later, Patrick held Emma and confided in his baby daughter about how concerned he is about his relationship with Robin. He promised to take care of his daughter. Just then, Robin entered. "I'm home," she said quietly. Patrick told her that he was going to look for her, but she replied that it was better she came back on her own. She explained that she wanted to be away from everything that was weighing her down. Patrick asked why she stopped in Rochester; she said that it was "random" and admitted to creating a whole new identity for herself. Still, she didn't mention Brad. "I think I have postpartum depression and I really need help," she concluded.

Spinelli was brought in to join Rayner, Diane and Jason. Diane kept saying that Rayner didn't have a case against the guys.... Sam made her way into a records room at the agency and grabbed Spinelli's case file (using a napkin so her fingerprints wouldn't get on it). She also opened his file on the computer and destroyed the evidence against him. Later, Rayner was informed that the evidence had been corrupted. Rayne blamed Spinelli and demanded to know who the last person who entered the records room was; the agent informed Rayner that Rayner was the last person who'd been there. He reluctantly told Diane that the guys were free to go, but warned that he wasn't backing off of them.