At the lake house, Alexis confronted Sam and Kristina on their whereabouts. Sam lied that they were at the mall, and felt conflicted about keeping Alexis in the dark that Kristina was preparing to lose her virginity. After Sam left, Alexis had a sit-down with Kristina to talk about "things." Alexis advised her daughter to focus on herself. Kristina, however, copped an attitude.

At the penthouse, Spinelli used the Internet to locate the box containing Devlin's possessions. Spinelli then donned a ski mask to assist Jason in his mission to retrieve the box. Jason said no way, and asked Sam to accompany him. Sam pointed out that they needed Spinelli to be computer-bound, and he acquiesced. On his computer, Spinelli guided the duo via earpiece on how to break in to the PCPD. Inside, they couldn't find anything. Then, Lucky burst in and found Sam, but Jason managed to hide.

After Sonny confronted Olivia at Metro Court about her break-up with Johnny, she made it clear that it wasn't about him. Olivia then spoke up about how much she still cared for Johnny and stormed out.

Upstairs, Claudia came on to Dominic and tried to take his shirt off. Since he was wearing a wire, Dom pushed her away and said, "There's no way in hell I'm sleeping with you." A panicked Ronnie listened in. Claudia was furious at being spurned — and called Dominic by his birth name, "Dante Falconeri" and mentioned that she overheard Kate and Olivia discussing him. Claudia threatened to turn Dom in to Sonny unless he became her sex slave. Dominic realized that Claudia had an ulterior motive for them sleeping together. As Claudia started to undress him, the cops arrived and placed Dominic under arrest. After, the cops brought Dominic to Ronnie. Dom insisted her could save the investigation but Ronnie booted him off the case. Dom vowed to finish the job.

At G.H., Maxie lamented to Robin about having to return her wedding gifts. Robin mentioned that Patrick was at Jake's for the karaoke competition. Maxie was surprised that Robin would let her man out alone. Robin stated he wasn't alone — he was with Louise, the Assistant District Attorney. "Have I taught you nothing?" Maxie wondered. Maxie encouraged Robin to spice things up with her husband.

At Jake's, Patrick and Louise arrived. Coleman had his new bartender, K.Z. (guest star Chikezie Eze of AMERICAN IDOL fame), get their drinks. Johnny arrived and ordered tequila shots and asked to keep them coming. K.Z. wanted to sing but Coleman told him to keep the drinks flowing. Just then, Olivia wandered in. K.Z. continued pestering Coleman to sing, and got his wish. As K.Z. offered a soulful rendition of "Against All Odds," Johnny stared at Olivia but she refused to return his glance. Coleman admonished K.Z., stating that because he was so good, no one else got up to sing. Patrick suggested he and Louise go home and hang with Robin.

Back at the house, Maxie concocted a plan for Robin to seduce Patrick. Robin was reluctant but went along with it. In an outrageous get-up, Robin surprised Patrick upon his arrival, but she was the one in for a surprise when he returned with Louise.

As Jake's, Johnny sat down at the piano and serenaded Olivia with "Try a Little Tenderness." Olivia was touched, but ran out, leaving Johnny crestfallen.

A furious Carly found Sonny at Metro Court and told him about Alexis keeping Kristina away from Michael. Carly asked Sonny to tell Alexis that she was overreacting. Just then, Sonny then caught Claudia coming out of the hotel. "What are you doing here?" he wondered.