Reva paid Marina a visit to keep busy and the moms bonded over being overprotective of their babies. Reva pointed out that Jeffrey purchased the stuffed tiger Henry is playing with. Then she asked Marina if she needs any help with housework. They folded laundry together. Marina urged Reva to get some rest but she refused.

Olivia told Emma to pack her bag for a trip to Chicago, frantic to get new clues on Natalia's whereabouts. Emma admitted to her mom that her erratic behavior is scaring her. In Chicago, Liv went to a bar and met a guy named Jonsey, Natalia's old boss. He said he hasn't seen Nat in years. Liv accused the guy of lying and demanded that he tell her Nat's whereabouts. Then she handcuffed herself to the bar until he gave her some info. Later, Josh called Liv to see if she wanted to play a game of pool. She asked him to come bail her out of jail in Chicago instead.

Phillip informed Alexandra that Alan told him about Vietnam and then later denied it. She confirmed that the story is true and that it was the defining moment in Alan's life and, for her, the moment she lost the brother she loves. Phil was shocked that Alan has been carrying around that guilt for so many years. "I don't think I've ever really known my father until now," he added. Alex then said Alan has been sending check's to the man's widow for years. Meanwhile, Alan rummaged through the attic and dug out his old draft card and a newspaper clipping about a young man who died in the war, leaving a wife and child behind. The duo confronted Alan who continued to deny their claims that he showed signs of guilt, remorse or even kindness by giving the widow money. He chalked it up to good publicity.

At Company, Ashlee told Mallet that she's working on a story about Jeffrey's life for WSPR and called him a hero, adding that whoever is responsible for his death deserves punishment. Later, at the police station, Mallet told a fellow officer that he doesn't want to see the stroller/murder weapon ever again. Dinah, meanwhile, helped Ash do voiceover work on Jeffrey's story and was overcome with emotion.

Reva went back home and Shayne stopped by. Reva told him that Dinah is a good woman and he's lucky he found her. He revealed that Dinah's working on a WSPR tribute for Jeffrey. Reva was touched and said she feels connected to Dinah in a way because she was the last person to see Jeffrey alive. Dinah also paid Reva a visit. Reva admitted she feels surprisingly close to La Marler. Dinah gave Reva a hug and promised to help her get through it all. Later, Reva paced around her house and was unable to settle down. She grabbed Jeffrey's guitar and hugged it.

Marina called Mallet to see if he wanted to come on a walk with her and Henry. He later listened to the voice mail and didn't return her call. Dinah saw him hanging out at the baseball field alone. He admitted he thinks he's crazy for believing his wife is a murderer. She urged him to move on. Marina went to Company where she ran into Ash, who talked about the Jeffrey video. "Jeffrey was a nice man but I wish everyone would just move on with their lives," she spat. Later, at home, Marina bitterly threw out the stuffed tiger that Jeffrey gave to Henry. Mallet then came home and urged his wife, one more time, to open up to him. Then he told her that he knows she killed the man she thought was Edmund.

At the mansion, Phillip did some research to find the widow's home address. He told Alan that he's thinking about taking another trip to visit some classic minor league baseball parks across the country for a few weeks. Alan offered to come along, much to Phil's surprise. Alan was intrigued by challenging Phil to prove he can hang with the dudes. After Phil left the room, Alan surmised that Phil's got something else up his sleeve, which is why he really agreed to go.

Shayne surprised Dinah with a bunch of balloons at the gazebo to "bring her back to her carnival days." Dinah said she's having trouble being happy, especially with everything that's going on with Reva and Jeffrey right now. Shayne pulled down a single red balloon and said he wants her to be happy. There was an engagement ring attached to the ballon. Shayne smiled and asked Dinah to marry him.