Starr told Miss Dickinson that the drugs belonged to her. Starr reassured her that she had a "prescription." Starr explained that the pills were antidepressants and that she forgot to give the nurse the prescription. When Miss Dickinson told Starr to give the nurse the prescription and walked off, Starr showed Cole an actual prescription that Dr. Joplin had given her. Starr then told Cole that she didn't need pills to ease her pain, unlike him. Cole confided that when Marty came to him on the night of Hope's birth, he thought it was a miracle but he was wrong. Starr implored Cole to think his decisions through, just like she had done when she decided to give up the baby for adoption. She told him that she would accept his decision and walked off. Cole took another pill.

Brody was shocked when Wes told him that the Iraqi boy didn't have a gun. Wes apologized to an inconsolable Brody. Wes explained that the little boy was pointing something at him and Brody shot him. When he realized he had shot a little boy, Wes couldn't calm him down. When Wes went to find the gun that the little boy had, he realized that it wasn't a gun — it was a flashlight. To protect Brody, Wes planted a gun in the boy's hand. Wes apologized to Brody and told him that at the time, he thought it was the right thing to do. Wes told Brody that he was still a good man and a good soldier. Brody thanked his buddy for telling him the truth as Wes left. When Brody was alone, he had a vision of the little boy again. Brody got down on his knees and cradled the "boy."

After kissing John, Marty told him she was trying one of her personalities out. Marty continued to play games with John and kissed him as Blair walked in. Marty explained that she had kissed John to see if any memories would come up and then went after Blair, inferring that she wasn't over Todd. Blair tried to contain her anger when Marty demanded to know why they had saved Todd on New Years Eve. Blair warned Marty to stay out of her business. Blair accused Marty of not being able to move on from the past. When Marty accused Blair of not wanting Todd to be with anyone else, Blair asked John to throw her out. She was shocked when he refused. An angry Blair stormed off. Marty gloated to John, who walked away from her. She met up with Wes.

Natalie and Jared arrived at the hospital with Chloe and ran into Marcie and Michael. Natalie told them that Chloe was just having a checkup. Natalie let Marcie hold the baby. Marcie noted that Hope would be the same age as Chloe. Viki called Natalie and asked her to come to the vineyard. Marcie and Michael babysat Chloe. The two discussed their marriage and how they wished things could have turned out better.

Bess explained to Tess that she had saved them after Tess didn't care for the baby. Bess explained to Tess that the baby didn't go to the prenatal appointments and ignored the contractions. Tess was horrified when she realized she could have saved the baby. Tess was horrified to when Bess told her she switched Jessica's baby with Starr's. Tess asked Bess if Jessica knew the truth. Bess revealed that she didn't tell Jessica the truth about the baby. She DID, however, tell Jessica another truth. Bess then explained to Tess that to protect Jessica they needed to integrate. Bess told Tess that her work was done and that it was time for Jessica to have some peace. The two held hands and disappeared into Jessica's head. "The secret's safe now. We can all rest," Bess said to herself.

Jessica didn't want to say what Bess had told her. Viki was confused when Jessica said she needed to talk to Natalie. When Natalie arrived, Jessica said, "I wanted you and Jared to die." Jessica revealed to the two of them that she had willingly let Tess come out so that she could kill them. Viki, Clint, Jared and Natalie tried to reason with Jessica but she wouldn't listen. Viki wasn't satisfied and told Clint that they still didn't know the truth about what happened the night of the birth. Clint wondered if they ever would.