At Tabitha's, Endora and her mom enjoyed eating food that Tabitha made from scratch. Tabby resented Miguel for making her prepare food and clean up using mortal methods. Tabitha zapped her kitchen clean, but Kay caught her in the act and reminded her that she'd promised to cease using magic. Tabby called Miguel a "bonehead" and noted that Miguel blackmailed her. She vowed to turn him into a toad. Kay demanded that Tabitha keep her promise to Miguel. Tabby planned to find the letter Miguel had, which exposed them as witches. A desperate Kay used magic to stop Tabitha, and a showdown ensued.

At the cottage, Luis and Sheridan lavished Marty with gifts. "I love being rich!" Marty cried, but Luis reminded him that it's his mother who has the money. Their family gathering was interrupted when Fancy arrived for her date with Luis. She and Sheridan argued, and Fancy accused Sheridan of using Marty to keep her hold on Luis. Luis intervened and called their disagreement silly. Fancy reminded him that they had a date, and was disappointed that he'd forgotten about it. Luis apologized for not being able to go because he'd made plans with Marty. Sheridan was pleased to watch Fancy lose out. Fancy told Luis that she saw him with Sheridan at the cottage after he ditched her on New Year's Eve. Sheridan was furious with her for spying. Luis insisted that he was only giving Sheridan a hug, and promised to make up the date with Fancy. Fancy didn't believe him and stormed out. Luis reminded Sheridan that Fancy is the woman he loves, and not her. Later, Fancy returned and asked Marty if they could be friends. Sheridan rolled her eyes when Luis kissed Fancy. Marty was thrilled when Fancy invited him and Luis to a hockey game.

A concerned Pilar asked Miguel if he'd seen Theresa. Miguel became worried when Pilar stated that Theresa was in danger. However, Pilar was happy when Miguel revealed that he and Kay were engaged. Miguel then overheard Tabitha and Kay fighting in the kitchen and went to stop them. He was furious with them for using magic and made them again promise not to do so.... Pilar said a prayer for Theresa when she realized her daughter was in Mexico.

Meanwhile, in Mexico, Theresa tried to get information on Juanita, but none of the woman's contacts would speak.... In her home Juanita approached one of her contacts while brandishing a knife; he was so frightened he got down on his knees and begged for his life. Juanita chuckled and explained that she had the knife because she was planning to make herself a sandwich, and then offered him some alcohol. The man was unnerved by her politeness. He agreed to a deal with Juanita where she got a percentage of everything he earned for the rest of his life. Juanita told the man her plans to get revenge on Pilar, then shot the man in the head. Wouldn't it had been better if she'd kept him alive so she could've gotten that money from him?

Theresa became nervous when someone knocked on her hotel room door. When she opened it, no one was there, but someone had left an envelope addressed to "Pilar's daughter." Theresa feared what would happen if she opened it, but she did and it said, "Leave Mexico or die!" Later, Juanita got word that Theresa was in Mexico and told her thugs to kill her.... Theresa managed to get Juanita's address and went to find her.