J.T. surprised Victoria with a romantic, candlelit dinner for their one-year anniversary. They also wanted to celebrate Noah surviving his fall through the ice. They sat down to enjoy their meal ... of Reed and Summer's leftovers. Then they had slices of their one-year-old wedding cake. Vicky was touched when J.T. gave her a paper bouquet; she gave him a framed black-and-white photo from their wedding.

A frantic Colleen left several more messages for Brad. Billy and Lily tried to keep her calm; they suggested that perhaps he just couldn't get cell phone reception. Colleen was still worried, though, and decided to call the police. She was told that they couldn't do anything since Brad had only been missing for a few hours. Billy noted that Brad could take care of himself. Coll wasn't convinced and decided to search for him herself.

At the Baldwins', Michael and Lauren scolded Eden for going skating in a storm with Noah. Eden apologized, but he was furious with her for lying to him. Lauren and Jana tried to calm him down, but he reminded his sister that she and Noah could've died. Eden stormed up to her room. Lauren tried to get Michael to see some perspective, but Michael was still angry. Lauren noted that they needed to give her a reasonable punishment. Upstairs, Eden complained to Jana about how Michael wouldn't let her say good-bye to Noah. Jana explained that Michael loves her, which is why he was so upset with her. Eden thought that Michael wanted her gone.... Michael admitted to Lauren that he wasn't sure he was cut out to parent a teenager. Lauren reminded him that Fen would eventually be a teenager. Lauren had faith in Michael's parenting abilities.... Eden explained to Jana how important Noah is to her. Later, Jana opined to Michael that Eden's a good kid and Michael's a good man. Lauren sat with Eden and tried to have a reasonable conversation with her, explaining why they were so angry. After, Eden and Michael made up

Meanwhile at the hospital, Nick and Phyllis were relieved to learn that Noah was going to make a full recovery. Noah again apologized for giving them a scare. The doctor told them that Noah could leave the hospital the next day ‹ and that the teen was lucky he'd escaped the water when he did. Jack thanked God for watching over him. Nick wanted to drive up to the Abbott cabin to fill in Sharon, but Phyllis didn't want him going out into the storm. Nick insisted, despite her pleas. "I have to do this. I owe this to Sharon," he explained.... Jack kept vigil by Noah. When Noah awakened, he asked about Eden; Jack told him that Eden wanted to see him but the doctor insisted that Noah needed his rest. Jack asked what Noah remembered about the accident, but all he could recall was falling into the ice. He worried that Sharon was going to kill him, then worried that Sharon wouldn't be able to deal with being in the cabin by herself. Jack was confident that she'd be fine.... Phyllis offered to go up to Sharon while Nick stayed with Noah. She also thought Jack could be a good person to do the job. Nick wanted Sharon to get the news from him. "Be careful," a defeated Phyllis told him as he headed out.

In the cabin, Sharon lit a fire and candles since the power was out and planned to burn the note she'd written to Nick.... Phyllis confided in Jack how she feared that Nick had feelings for Sharon. Phyllis decided to find Nick. Jack urged her not to be so paranoid. Later, Nick arrived at the cabin and told Sharon about Noah. She wanted to go see her son. On her way, a police officer told Phyllis it was too dangerous to drive. Sharon and Nick were given the same message up at the cabin. Sharon freaked out, but Nick assured her that Noah was okay. He promised to help Sharon make it through the night and embraced her.

Colleen interrupted Victoria and J.T.'s romantic evening and explained how concerned she was about Brad. Victoria was very understanding, recalling how worried she was when Victor was missing. Colleen felt badly about ruining their dinner.... Billy and Lily got cozy as they awaited word from Brad. He invited Lily to go up to the cabin with him for Valentine's Day. She wasn't sure because the day reminded her of her first time with Cane. She agreed to think about spending the weekend with Billy... J.T. offered to help Colleen look for her father, but they had no luck.