Chloe chirped to Jack that Billy has been acting great to her. Meanwhile, Billy impressed on Sharon (who was emotional about Cassie) that he didn't want Jack to know that Billy could be the father of her baby. Sharon revealed that Jack already knows that she slept with someone else but she didn't name Billy. Jack showed up and asked what they were talking about. Billy left and Sharon explained that he was worried that she would hurt Jack again. He urged her to just relax but she insisted that she needed to tell Nick about the pregnancy. Jack immediately tried to dissuade from saying anything before the paternity is determined by citing Summer. "You'd be tearing apart a marriage and turning that little girl's world upside down,” he pointed out and Sharon finally agreed not to say anything to Nick.

Chloe found Billy's cell and saw that Mac called. Meanwhile, Katherine prepared for tomorrow's barbeque party and warned Mac that Billy and Chloe would be invited. Mac confessed that she still cares for Billy but would never want him to leave Chloe because he would miss his daughter. Later, Chloe showed up and asked Mac why she called Billy. Mac explained it was made on impulse and that she didn't even leave a message. Chloe complained that Mac is interfering with her happiness by distracting Billy. Mac assured she isn't a threat to Chloe's marriage. Chloe was then surprised to hear that Mac and Billy never had sex. Mac also revealed that she was recently seriously involved with someone else. Billy arrived and overheard Chloe suggest that Mac invite this guy to the barbeque.

Paul told Mary Jane that is it "driving me nuts" that they may have met before. Paul invited her to lunch and she reluctantly accepted. As they dined Paul asked where MJ was from and where she went to college. Paul suddenly recognized her laugh and asked if she knew his ex-wife April since she lives in New York too. MJ claimed to have a migraine and left. Paul then initiated a complete background check on her.

On the anniversary of Cassie's death, Nick couldn't stop thinking about her. "They say this is supposed to get easier," he lamented to Phyllis. "I'd like to know when that is." Nick also confessed that he felt guilty for Sharon becoming an emotional mess and that he wants to help her. "I can't sit back and watch her go under," he insisted. "This is my fault." Phyllis advised her husband to let Sharon work on her marriage but he refused to believe that's what his ex really wants. "I don't want you to think for one second that I don't need you as much as Sharon does," Phyllis reminded. She then had to leave to look at a wedding dress for Nikki. Once his wife was gone, Nick tried to call Sharon but she wouldn't answer his call.