Ashley confided in Adam that she'd been having some weird dreams and he was in one. He promised to help her sort everything out. She recalled driving during a rainstorm and hitting Sabrina. Adam promised not to tell anyone about it. Ashley crawled into her bed and hugged her pillow.

At the Newman Ranch, Victor informed Victoria and Nick that Nikki called off her wedding to Paul and left town. However, he didn't know where Nikki was going. Victoria was surprised that Nikki had gone to him instead of her or Nick. After Victor stepped away, Nick and Victoria discussed the situation. "Someone can be the love of your life. That doesn't necessarily mean you're gonna spend the rest of your life with them," said Nick. "Don't let Ashley hear you say that," replied Victoria.

At the church, a despondent Paul sat down with his head in his hands. Father Todd joined him and gave his brother a sympathetic smile. "I didn't see it coming," Paul sighed. "Victor's got this hold on her, and it's sad. I'll get over this," he added, "but Nikki's trapped." Todd noted that it was natural for Paul to be angry, but pointed out that by walking away, Nikki had done a brave thing. A tearful Paul argued that he and Nikki were great together, and that being with Nikki made him happy. Victoria later found Paul at the church and apologized for Nikki leaving. She added that they would've been honored to have him join the family. Paul was sincerely touched. Later, Paul took a quiet moment for himself. "Goodbye, Nikki," he whispered before leaving the church.

Billy came by the Chancellor Estate and played it cool with Mac in front of Chloe. Chance and Katherine joined them and Chance informed Chloe that he got the detective job. Chloe was thrilled, though Kay feared the job wasn't safe enough. Chloe continued to push the idea of Mac and Chance hooking up, but Mac and Billy insisted that Chance wasn't interested. Kay got Chloe out of the room by informing her that Cordelia was awake. After Chloe stepped out, Mac implored Billy to tell Chloe the truth about them being together, but Billy wanted to find the right moment.

At the station, Sharon asked Rafe to be her attorney and explained that she accidentally left the store with the ring, arguing that being pregnant, she couldn't outrun a security guard. Jack soon arrived and wanted to call Michael, but Sharon didn't think Baldwin would want to represent her. Jack didn't believe that her stealing was an "accident" and urged her to get help. Chance then went to the station and was happy to be reintroduced to Jack. Detective Wallace explained that Chance was new on the force. Rafe warned Sharon that she'd probably have to spend the night there.... Jack called Nick regarding Sharon. Nick arrived and Jack implored him to get Sharon to seek professional help. Nick paid Sharon a visit, but she wasn't happy to see him. She reamed him out when he called her "self destructive," insisting that she just made a mistake. Nick replied that he believed her. However, he was shocked when he saw the ring she'd taken and realized it was exactly like the one he'd given Phyllis.

Billy went to the ranch to see Ashley. She was thrilled to have him visit. She then broke down as she filled him in on Zapato dying and how she's been having nightmares. Billy was concerned for her and called Victor "a controlling, manipulative freak." Ashley insisted that she's going to be okay, but then admitted that she's been seeing Sabrina ‹ and dreamed that she hit her with her car. Billy reminded her that Sabrina is dead so she couldn't hurt her. She cracked a smile as Billy compared Sabrina to a cartoon that you could do anything to and it would keep coming back. She thanked him for being a good brother.... Adam went to car Ashley had been driving and examined it. As he did so, he spoke out loud to himself, calling Ashley a cruel name. He then found a dent on the car, indicating that Ash really had hit something.

Chloe planned to include Mac and Chance in a spread in Restless Style about Genoa City's adventurers, but Mac wasn't into the idea. Later, Chloe ran into Mac at Crimson Lights and again mentioned Chance. Mac became angry and revealed that she and Billy are together.

Victor stopped by the estate and told Kay about Nikki calling off the wedding and leaving town. Kay wanted to know if Victor had anything to do with it, but Victor denied it. Kay stated that Nikki still loves him. Victor insisted that he didn't tell Nikki to leave Paul. "What I regret is that she left so suddenly because there were more things I wanted to say to her," he explained. "Now I don't have a chance to do that."

Billy and Jack met up at the G.C.A.C. Billy informed his brother that Ashley is "losing it."... Adam informed Ashley that there really was a dent on the car's fender, and that he remembered her leaving the house. "Ashley, I think you killed Sabrina," he said gravely.